The Montgomery County Council voted 6-5 on Tuesday, Nov. 10, to keep the Dickerson Resource Recovery Facility open as the county's long-term waste disposal method.

The decision rejected County Executive Marc Elrich's recommendation to close the incinerator and shift to hauling trash to out-of-county landfills. Council staff had framed the choice as a binary one: keep the Dickerson facility or close it and move to long-haul disposal, Moderately MoCo reported.

Council President Natali Fani-González, lead sponsor of both competing resolutions, said the Council had "fully explored all the issues and are moving forward with the most effective solution for our community."

Voting yes: Fani-González, Councilmembers Shebra Evans, Evan Glass, Sidney Katz, Dawn Luedtke and Kate Stewart. Voting no: Council Vice President Marilyn Balcombe, Councilmembers Andrew Friedson, Will Jawando, Kristin Mink and Laurie-Anne Sayles. Moderately MoCo has the full breakdown of each member's reasoning.

What it means for residents

The resolution asks Elrich to begin planning capital upgrades the incinerator needs to run reliably and meet permit requirements. It also calls for a new in-county food-waste composting facility. The Council has already set aside $28 million for that composting project, which could be built at the existing yard-trim site in Dickerson or another location.

Council staff wrote that the feasibility and final cost of the incinerator upgrade would need to be confirmed through additional planning and requests for proposals.

Neither resolution set truck routes, hauling hours or protections for neighborhoods near the Shady Grove Transfer Station. In a Nov. 5 letter to the Council, Elrich wrote that either option would require short-term long-haul trucking during the facility's refurbishment.

Rockville City Councilmember Adam Van Grack, who had raised concerns about long-haul trucks at Shady Grove, wrote to residents after the vote that the decision was correct given the two proposed options, though not perfect. He said he will be watching for the possibility that temporary long-haul trucking could still be needed during major renovations.

The resolution asks the county executive to address each measure in the amended fiscal year 2027-2032 Capital Improvements Program.