A Maryland appeals court ruled that a novel written by a former Thomas S. Wootton High School student constituted a criminal threat of mass violence.

The Appellate Court of Maryland on Oct. 28 upheld the conviction of Alex Ye, now 20, who was found guilty in January 2025 of one misdemeanor count of threatening to commit mass violence. The case, first reported by the Maryland Daily Record, turned on whether a 129-page novel Ye wrote and shared with two friends over Instagram amounted to a "true threat" unprotected by the First Amendment.

The court held that a fiction disclaimer in Ye's book did not prevent his writing from being found a "true threat," given the context of his statements and the reaction of a recipient who called police.

What happened

Ye sent the book to two friends via Instagram at 12:46 a.m. on March 3, 2024, according to the appellate opinion. The novel's opening lines read: "I want to shoot up my school. I've been preparing for it for the past few months. … This gun is going to change lives tomorrow."

One of the two recipients, identified in court records as Maxwell, called police after reading the first few pages. Ye had previously acknowledged homicidal ideations to a school therapist, and Wootton had issued a no-trespass order against him. He was enrolled in virtual school at the time.

Ye told his friend the novel was highly autobiographical and explored the life of an "almost school shooter," according to the Daily Record's account of court records. The book's protagonist was a Chinese American, transgender teen who wrestled with the desire to kill but eventually sought help at a psychiatric hospital.

The novel included a disclaimer stating it was "a work of fiction" and "not a threat of violence, nor does it represent the author's beliefs." That disclaimer was not included in the portion Ye sent to Maxwell, the court found.

The court's reasoning

Judge Kathryn Graeff, writing for a three-judge panel that included Judges Terrence Zic and Robert Zarnoch, ruled the lower court was right to find Ye posed a "true threat."

The context mattered.

Graeff wrote that Ye's statements in the book, combined with his statements that the writing was based on his own thoughts and experiences, "permitted a reasonable inference that appellant was going to act on his expressed desire to commit a school shooting."

The court found that a fiction disclaimer "does not insulate a defendant from the finding that the statement was a true threat," the Daily Record reported. Maxwell's alarmed reaction and his belief that there was a real threat were "significant" in the court's analysis, Graeff wrote.

Sentence and investigation

Police arrested Ye on April 16, 2024, 44 days after learning of the book. A search warrant turned up internet searches for AR-15 descriptions, the minimum age for a gun range and information on previous school shooters, according to the court opinion. Police found no firearm in Ye's home, though they did not search the entire residence.

Ye was originally sentenced to 10 years in prison, with all but 12 months suspended. The Montgomery County Circuit Court later reduced the unsuspended portion to 140 days, plus five years of supervised probation. The sentence concluded in spring 2026, the Daily Record reported.

Ye's defense attorneys and the Maryland Office of the Attorney General both declined to comment, the Daily Record reported.

The case was prosecuted under Maryland Criminal Law § 3-1001(b), which prohibits knowingly making a threat of mass violence.